Digital Fairness Act: what the EU proposal would change for UK traders

In short: The Digital Fairness Act is a proposal the European Commission published on 11 November 2026, and it has not been adopted. If adopted, a trader selling to EU consumers would need an online cancel button, reminders before free trials end and contracts renew, and consent for SMS and email marketing, with Commission fines of up to 6% of worldwide turnover.
A UK business that sells to consumers in the EU, or markets to them by email and text message, would have to change its sign-up, renewal, cancellation and marketing practices if the Digital Fairness Act is adopted as proposed. The European Commission presented the text on 11 November 2026. The European Parliament and the Council have not yet agreed it, the text may change, and none of it applies today. As drafted, the rules would apply 12 months after the Act comes into force.
The Commission published three linked proposals in its consumer package (IP/26/2407): the Digital Fairness Act, COM(2026) 1100, a regulation that would replace the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive; a simplification directive, COM(2026) 1110, which would amend the Consumer Rights Directive and the ePrivacy Directive; and a new Consumer Protection Cooperation (CPC) Regulation, COM(2026) 1120, under which the Commission could itself investigate and fine traders.
Signing up, renewing and leaving
Under the proposed Digital Fairness Act, a trader that offers a free trial online would have to remind the consumer, on a durable medium and a reasonable time before the trial ends, of the end date, the price and how to cancel. If the trader does not send the reminder, or the consumer does not expressly agree before the end of the trial to continue on a paid basis, the consumer would not be bound by the contract (Article 20).
For a contract of six months or more concluded online that renews automatically, the trader would have to send a reminder no earlier than one month and no later than 14 days before the renewal date (Article 21). Shorter contracts would need a reminder at the latest one week before the renewal that takes the contract to six months, or before its tenth renewal if that comes first (Article 22). If the trader misses the reminder, the consumer could cancel free of charge at any time until it is sent. Once a contract has rolled over for an indefinite period, the consumer could end it on no more than one month’s notice.
Any trader that lets consumers sign up online would have to provide an online cancellation function labelled “terminate the contract here”, or with equally clear words, whatever channel the consumer used to sign up, and acknowledge a cancellation within a week (Article 23). A matching withdrawal function would apply to distance contracts concluded online, including contracts for financial services (Article 24). Where a trader provides online customer service after the contract is concluded, the consumer could ask to speak to a person when other means have not worked; investment services are excluded (Article 25).
The UK has separate subscription contracts rules in the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCCA 2024), which are not yet in force and which have their own reminder windows and exit requirements. A provider that serves both markets from one sign-up journey would have to meet both.
Interface design, personalisation and minors
A trader could not design, organise or operate an online interface in a way likely to deceive or manipulate consumers or otherwise materially distort their economic behaviour (Article 10 of the proposed Digital Fairness Act). An annex lists dark patterns that would be unfair in all circumstances, and the Commission could add to the list. The Commission also proposes to delete Article 16e of the Consumer Rights Directive, the specific rule on online interfaces for financial services distance contracts, because Article 10 would apply to those contracts.
A trader could not target advertising by profiling, within the meaning of Article 4(4) of the GDPR, using the data of a consumer it knows with reasonable certainty to be a minor, or using special category data such as health or religious belief (Article 12). Online platform providers already subject to the advertising rules in the Digital Services Act would be outside Article 12. A trader could not personalise prices by profiling in a way reasonably likely to harm the consumer where it knows with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor or vulnerable (Article 13).
Where a product is directed at minors, or the trader knows with reasonable certainty that minors use it, paid-for virtual currencies would be disabled for minors unless a parent or guardian approves, and paid-for variable reward systems, such as loot boxes, and pay-to-win mechanisms could not be offered to minors (Articles 14 to 16). Some social media, video-sharing and chatbot services would instead be covered by the proposed EU KIDS Act. A trader whose service is intended or reasonably foreseeable to encourage compulsive or excessive use would have to let users switch off features such as autoplay, unprompted notifications and streak-style rewards (Article 17). Influencer marketing would have to carry the words “advertisement” or “commercial collaboration” (Article 11).
Email, SMS and marketing calls
Under Article 28 of the proposed Digital Fairness Act, a trader would need the consumer’s prior consent, in the GDPR sense, before marketing by automated calls, SMS, MMS or email. An existing-customer exception would allow a trader that obtained a customer’s electronic mail details in the context of a sale or supply to market its own similar products, if the consumer can object free of charge at collection and in every message. For live marketing calls, a Member State could allow calls to consumers who have not opted out, in place of consent.
The simplification directive would add a new paragraph to Article 13 of the ePrivacy Directive so that Article 13 no longer applies to traders marketing to consumers. Marketing by a trader to EU consumers would then be subject to the Digital Fairness Act alone, and a breach would be a breach of consumer law, open to consumer law penalties. In EU-wide cases involving larger traders, the Commission’s proposed fining power would also apply, except to the live-call rule. The consent rule itself is close to Article 13 as it stands. The existing-customer exception is drafted by reference to electronic mail, while Article 28(1) lists SMS separately, so it is unclear whether a trader could rely on the exception for text messages.
In the UK, regulation 22 of the Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003 (PECR) would continue to apply to marketing to UK consumers. Under regulation 22, the soft opt-in extends to text messages and to details obtained in negotiations for a sale, and a charity exception has applied since 5 February 2026. A business that uses one consent and preference model for UK and EU customers would have to meet both regimes. UK law assesses consent objectively, as the Court of Appeal held in RTM v Bonne Terre Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 488.
Fines, Commission enforcement and EU representatives
In coordinated cross-border cases, Member States would have to make fines available with a maximum of at least 4% of the trader’s annual turnover in the Member States concerned, or at least €2 million where turnover figures are not available (Article 35 of the proposed Digital Fairness Act). A Member State could, for national constitutional reasons, limit those fines to certain infringements, which include the Chapter III rules described above.
Under the proposed new CPC Regulation, the Commission could investigate an infringement that harms, or is likely to harm, consumers in at least two-thirds of Member States, together holding at least two-thirds of the EU population (Article 3(4)). Where it finds that the trader intentionally or negligently infringed the Digital Fairness Act, it could impose a fine of up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover (Article 43). Micro, small and medium-sized enterprises would be outside the Commission’s direct powers (Article 31).
A trader with no EU establishment that targets EU consumers would have to appoint a legal representative in a Member State where it sells, and publish the representative’s contact details on its website (Article 59). Appointing a representative would not of itself create an EU establishment. The regulatory perimeter and market entry page covers how UK firms structure their entry into regulated markets.
| What a trader would have to do | Proposed EU rule (not yet law) | UK position |
|---|---|---|
| Remind before a free trial ends | Reminder on a durable medium; consumer not bound without it and express agreement (DFA Article 20) | DMCCA 2024 subscription contracts rules, not yet in force |
| Remind before automatic renewal | One month to 14 days before renewal for contracts of six months or more (DFA Article 21) | DMCCA 2024 subscription contracts rules, not yet in force |
| Let consumers cancel online | “Terminate the contract here” function, whatever the sign-up channel (DFA Article 23) | DMCCA 2024 subscription contracts rules, not yet in force |
| Obtain consent for SMS and email marketing | Prior consent; existing-customer exception drafted by reference to email; SMS position unclear (DFA Article 28) | PECR regulation 22: soft opt-in covers SMS and negotiations for a sale; charity exception |
| Fines | Maximum of at least 4% of turnover in the Member States concerned; Commission up to 6% of worldwide turnover in EU-wide cases (DFA Article 35; CPC Article 43) | CMA direct enforcement under the DMCCA 2024; ICO for PECR |
Viewpoint
Parts of the Digital Fairness Act build on rules EU traders already follow: consent for email marketing comes from Article 13 of the ePrivacy Directive, and the withdrawal function comes from Article 11a of the Consumer Rights Directive. The larger change is in enforcement. A turnover-based fine floor in every Member State, and a Commission able to investigate and fine on its own account, would raise the cost of getting sign-up, renewal and marketing journeys wrong.
For UK businesses the practical issue is running two sets of rules. Neither the UK subscription contracts rules nor PECR would change as a result of these proposals, so a firm that sells into both markets would have to choose between one journey built to the stricter standard and two separate journeys. The SMS point is the one I would watch as the European Parliament and the Council work through the text: the ePrivacy Directive’s definition of electronic mail in Article 2(h), like the PECR definition in regulation 2(1), includes text messages, and the Commission’s proposal does not say whether that reading carries over.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Digital Fairness Act law?
No. The European Commission presented the Digital Fairness Act as a proposal on 11 November 2026 (COM(2026) 1100). The European Parliament and the Council must agree it, and the text may change. As drafted, it would apply 12 months after it comes into force, and that period is still in square brackets in the text.
Would the Digital Fairness Act apply to UK businesses?
It would apply to business-to-consumer practices directed at consumers in the EU wherever the trader is based, as the current Unfair Commercial Practices Directive does. It would not change UK law. A UK trader with no EU establishment that targets EU consumers would also have to appoint an EU legal representative under the proposed new CPC Regulation (Article 59).
What would change for SMS and email marketing?
Article 28 would require prior consent for marketing by automated calls, SMS, MMS and email, with an existing-customer exception that, as drafted, refers to electronic mail obtained on a sale or supply. Breaches would be enforced as consumer law, and Article 13 of the ePrivacy Directive would no longer apply to traders marketing to consumers. PECR regulation 22 would continue to apply in the UK.
What are the proposed fines?
In coordinated cross-border cases, Member States would have to make fines available with a maximum of at least 4% of annual turnover in the Member States concerned, or at least €2 million where turnover data is unavailable. The Commission could fine up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover for intentional or negligent infringements affecting at least two-thirds of Member States. Micro, small and medium-sized enterprises would be outside the Commission’s direct powers.
For advice on how the proposed Digital Fairness Act would affect your EU sign-up, renewal and marketing journeys, contact Rob Bratby at Bratby Law.
This post was researched and drafted with the help of Claude, Anthropic’s AI model. Rob Bratby chose the topic and thesis, and reviewed and edited the final post. Rob takes full responsibility for its content.
